Consumer Terms Guide / Privacy & data

Cookie banners explained: consent, reject all and the new UK rules

Plasticine illustration for the guide “Cookie banners explained: consent, reject all and the new UK rules”

With cookie banners explained in one sentence: a site must ask before it puts anything non-essential on your device, and you must be free to say no. Almost every banner you see, fair or annoying, is a reaction to that rule. Knowing what the law requires makes it easier to spot which ones are playing fair.

The rule does not come from the GDPR. It comes from Article 5(3) of the ePrivacy Directive in the EU, and regulation 6 of the Privacy and Electronic Communications Regulations 2003 (PECR) in the UK. The GDPR then sets the standard for what counts as consent. Cookies sit alongside the wider rules covered in our guide to the privacy policy explained.

What counts as valid consent

Consent must meet the GDPR standard: freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous, shown by a clear positive action. For a cookie banner, that translates into some concrete tests.

  • Non-essential cookies must not be set before you choose.
  • Boxes must not be pre-ticked. The EU Court of Justice said so in the Planet49 case in October 2019.
  • Scrolling or carrying on browsing is not consent.
  • Each purpose, such as analytics or advertising, should be selectable separately.
  • Withdrawing consent must be as easy as giving it, usually through a persistent link or icon.

Strictly necessary cookies are the exception. A cookie that keeps your basket full or your login active does not need consent, because the service you asked for cannot work without it.

Why reject all matters

The UK regulator has said for years that rejecting should be as easy as accepting. In the EU, the EDPB cookie banner taskforce report from January 2023 recorded that a clear majority of national authorities consider a banner with an accept button but no reject option on the first layer to be a breach.

The same report looked at other tricks: a reject link styled as faint text, an accept button in a bright colour, or a second layer that takes five clicks to get through. Authorities treated many of these as making consent invalid. If a banner pushes you hard towards accepting, that design is the problem, not you.

Clicking reject all is safe. Sites keep working, because essential cookies stay on. You may need to accept embedded videos or maps one at a time.

Some sites now offer a different choice: accept tracking or pay a subscription for an ad-free version. Regulators have not banned this model, but they expect the paid option to be reasonably priced and the free option to be a real alternative. A banner that leaves you only the choice between tracking and leaving the site altogether is unlikely to produce freely given consent.

Legitimate interest toggles

Many banners built on industry consent frameworks have a second tab with switches labelled legitimate interest, already set to on. This confuses almost everyone.

Those switches usually cover what advertising companies do with data under the GDPR after it has been collected, such as measuring ads or building audience segments. They are not a substitute for consent to place the cookie in the first place. Under the ePrivacy rules, non-essential storage on your device still needs consent. You can turn the toggles off, and doing so counts as objecting under Article 21 of the GDPR. The right to object is covered in more detail in your rights under GDPR.

What changed in the UK for low-risk cookies

The Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 rewrote regulation 6 of PECR and added a new list of exceptions. They took effect on 5 February 2026.

Two of them matter for banners. A site may now set cookies without consent where the only purpose is to collect statistics on how its service is used so that it can improve it, and the data is not shared except to help make those improvements. It may also set cookies whose only purpose is to adapt the site’s appearance or functions to your preferences, such as remembering a language or layout choice.

Both come with conditions. The site must give you clear and comprehensive information about the purpose, and offer a simple and free way to object. If you object, the cookie should not be used. Strictly necessary cookies keep their exemption, and the list of examples now expressly includes security, fraud prevention and remembering what you entered on a form.

Advertising and tracking across other sites are not covered. Those still need consent. The same Act also brought maximum PECR fines in line with UK GDPR levels, which gives the ICO more weight against sites that ignore the rules.

So expect UK banners to change shape. Some will drop the analytics toggle and instead show a notice with an opt-out link. That is lawful if the conditions are met. It is not lawful if the opt-out is hidden or the analytics data is sold on.

EU rules have not moved in the same way

In the EU, Article 5(3) of the ePrivacy Directive still requires consent for anything beyond what is strictly necessary, and national authorities apply it to most analytics cookies. A site serving both markets may therefore show different banners to UK and EU visitors.

If a banner does not let you refuse, you can complain to the site and then to the ICO or your national data protection authority. Browser settings that block third-party cookies help too, though they do not stop first-party tracking or fingerprinting. Clearing cookies regularly has a side effect worth knowing: the site forgets your refusal as well, so the banner returns. That is not a trick by the site. A stored choice needs a small cookie of its own, which counts as strictly necessary.

Questions and answers

Is it safe to click reject all on a cookie banner?

Yes. Rejecting non-essential cookies does not stop a site from working. Strictly necessary cookies, such as those that keep you logged in or hold your basket, do not need consent and stay active. What you lose is mostly personalised advertising and some embedded content like videos from third-party platforms, which you can usually enable individually later.

Why do some banners have no reject button?

Often because the site is cutting corners. The UK regulator says rejecting should be as easy as accepting, and the European Data Protection Board's cookie banner taskforce found that most EU authorities treat a missing reject option on the first layer as a breach. A banner that only offers accept or a settings page buried behind several clicks is unlikely to meet the consent standard.

What does legitimate interest mean in cookie settings?

Some settings panels include a second set of switches labelled legitimate interest, already turned on. These usually relate to how advertising partners use data after it is collected, under the GDPR. They do not replace consent for placing non-essential cookies on your device. You can switch them off, which is an objection under Article 21 of the GDPR.

Do cookie banners apply to apps as well?

Yes. The rules cover any technology that stores or reads information on your device, not only browser cookies. That includes software development kits in mobile apps, tracking pixels, local storage and device fingerprinting. The UK amendments in the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 expressly treat apps as websites for the new exceptions, so the same consent and objection rules apply.

Key points

PECR regulation 6
The UK rule on storing and reading information on your device; the EU version is Article 5(3) of the ePrivacy Directive.
Planet49 (2019)
The EU Court of Justice ruled that a pre-ticked box is not valid consent to cookies.
5 February 2026
UK sites may set some analytics and functionality cookies without consent, if you can object simply and free.

More from Privacy & data

All 4 guides