Refund policy explained: shop rules and your legal rights
A refund policy explained in one sentence: it can give you more than the law requires, but never less. Every shop’s returns page sits on top of a legal floor set by the Consumer Rights Act 2015 and the Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013 in the UK, and by the Consumer Rights Directive and the Sale of Goods Directive (EU) 2019/771 in the EU.
The confusion usually starts because the policy and the law are written into the same page. Separating them is the useful skill.
Two layers in every returns page
Think of a returns policy as having a statutory layer and a goodwill layer. The statutory layer covers faulty goods, items not as described, and the 14-day cooling-off period for online and phone orders. The shop cannot remove any of it.
The goodwill layer is everything extra. A 30-day or 100-day change-of-mind window, free return postage, a returns desk in every branch, an extended holiday returns period: all of these are commercial choices. The shop can attach conditions, change them for future orders and decide how to refund you.
A good policy tells you which layer each promise belongs to. Many do not, which is why a line such as “returns accepted within 28 days with receipt” can look like the full extent of your rights when it only describes the voluntary part.
What a refund policy cannot override by law
In the UK, section 31 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 says a term is not binding if it excludes or restricts the trader’s liability for goods that are faulty, not as described or not fit for purpose. The same applies to restrictions on the remedies, such as a clause saying you can only get an exchange. Section 47 does the same for digital content, and section 57 for services.
The EU equivalent sits in two places. Article 25 of the Consumer Rights Directive says consumers cannot waive the rights it gives them, so a seller cannot shorten the 14-day right of withdrawal. Article 21 of the Sale of Goods Directive says the same for the two-year legal guarantee on faulty goods.
So a returns policy that says any of the following does not change your position:
- faulty items can only be exchanged, never refunded
- returns must be made in the original packaging
- sale items cannot be returned
- you must contact the manufacturer, not the shop
Original packaging is a fair request for a goodwill return. For a faulty item, or an online purchase you are cancelling, the shop cannot insist on it, although you are responsible for any loss in value caused by handling the goods more than necessary. Our guide to faulty goods rights sets out the remedies that sit underneath every policy.
Shop purchases and change of mind
This is where a policy matters most, because the law gives you nothing here. Walk into a shop, buy a coat, decide at home that the colour is wrong, and you have no legal right to return it. The Citizens Advice guide to returning goods makes the same point.
Most large retailers accept such returns anyway. When they do, the policy is a contractual promise, so the shop has to honour what it said at the time you bought. If the receipt says 28 days and you come back on day 20 with the tags on, the shop cannot invent a new rule at the till.
Online orders are different. The 14-day cooling-off period applies whatever the returns page says, covered in our guide to the right to cancel an online purchase. A shop can extend that period, but it cannot shorten it or make it conditional on unused packaging.
Store credit, vouchers and exchanges
Store credit is legitimate in a goodwill return. A shop that takes back an unwanted item it had no duty to accept can choose to give you a credit note, an exchange or a gift card instead of cash.
When you are using a legal right, the position flips. A refund after cancelling an online order must go back through the same payment method unless you expressly agree otherwise. In the UK, a refund after rejecting faulty goods must be made without undue delay and within 14 days of the trader agreeing that you are entitled to it, again without a fee. A credit note is only acceptable if you choose it.
Expiry dates on credit notes
Gift cards and store credit often carry an expiry date. For a goodwill credit note that is usually allowed, as long as it was made clear. If a shop issues store credit when it should have given you a refund, you can ask for the refund instead.
Sale items, seconds and ex-display goods
Sale goods carry the same legal protection as full-price goods. A discount does not reduce your statutory rights, and a “no returns on sale items” line can only apply to change-of-mind returns in a shop.
Seconds and ex-display items are slightly different. If the shop pointed out a specific defect before you bought, such as a scratch on a fridge door, you cannot later reject the fridge because of that scratch. Any other fault is still covered. The same logic applies to refurbished phones and returned stock sold at a discount.
Reading a returns page before you buy
A few quick checks save most arguments. Look for who pays return postage on online orders: the shop can make you pay, but only if it told you before you bought. Check whether the change-of-mind window starts on the purchase date or the delivery date. Note whether refunds go back to your card or come as credit.
Then check the gap between the goodwill promise and the law. A policy offering 30 days to return unwanted items says nothing about what happens when a product fails after four months. That situation is covered by statute, not by the policy, and the shop still has to deal with it. Payment protection such as a card chargeback also exists outside anything a returns page says.
Questions and answers
Can a shop refuse a refund if I just changed my mind?
In a physical shop, yes. There is no legal right to return goods bought in person simply because you no longer want them, so any return is a goodwill gesture on the shop's terms. Online and phone purchases are different: there you have a 14-day cooling-off period under UK and EU law, whatever the shop's policy says.
Is a no refunds sign legal?
A sign or term that suggests you have no rights at all is misleading. In the UK, the Consumer Rights Act 2015 makes such a term non-binding for faulty goods, and wording that hides statutory rights can amount to a misleading practice under consumer protection law. A shop may say it does not give refunds for change of mind, as long as it does not imply faulty goods are excluded.
Do I have to accept store credit instead of money?
Only if the return is a goodwill one. When you use a legal right, such as cancelling an online order or rejecting faulty goods within 30 days in the UK, the seller must refund you through your original payment method unless you agree otherwise. You are free to accept a voucher, but you cannot be forced to.
Can a shop refuse a return without a receipt?
A shop can ask for proof of purchase, but a till receipt is not the only kind. A bank or card statement, an order confirmation email or the packaging record can show where and when you bought the item. For goodwill returns the shop can set stricter conditions, including insisting on the original receipt.
